Don't Take the Bait
How to Recognize and Avoid Insurance Scams Targeting You and Your Family
Scammers are increasingly targeting insurance policyholders — knowing their tactics, red flags, and how to verify who you're really talking to could save you from serious financial and personal harm.
Insurance scams are on the rise. Fraudsters have grown more sophisticated, and they know that people trust their insurance providers with sensitive personal and financial information. Increasingly, scammers are pretending to be representatives of well-known, trusted companies — including insurance carriers like North Carolina Farm Bureau — in order to steal money, personal data, or both.
At North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance Group, protecting our clients is not just a priority — it is a core part of who we are. We want you to be informed, confident, and safe. This article will walk you through the most common scam tactics being used today, the red flags to watch for, and exactly what to do if you believe you've been targeted.
How Insurance Scams Work
Most insurance-related scams follow a recognizable playbook, even if the details vary. A scammer will contact you — by phone, email, text message, or even in person — claiming to represent a legitimate company. They may use official-sounding language, spoof a real phone number so your caller ID looks genuine, or even reference real details about you or your policy to appear credible.
Their goal is to create urgency. They want you to act quickly before you have time to think, verify, or call someone you trust. Common scenarios include:
Fake policy renewal or cancellation notices — You receive an urgent call or message claiming your policy is about to lapse and you must make an immediate payment to keep your coverage active.
Impersonation of your insurance agent — Someone calls posing as your local agent, asking you to update your payment information or confirm sensitive account details.
Phishing emails or fake websites — A convincing email or website directs you to "log in" to your account, capturing your username and password in the process.
Post-disaster fraud — After a storm or natural disaster, unlicensed "contractors" or fraudulent adjusters contact homeowners, pressuring them to sign over insurance benefits or pay upfront for repairs.
Premium refund scams — A scammer tells you that you are owed a refund on your premiums, then asks for your banking details to "deposit" the funds.
Red Flags to Watch For
Scammers rely on confusion and pressure. The more you know about the warning signs, the harder it is for them to succeed. Be on high alert any time you encounter the following:
Unusual urgency — You're told you must act immediately or face serious consequences, such as policy cancellation, legal action, or loss of a discount.
Requests for unusual payment methods — Legitimate companies do not ask for gift cards, wire transfers, Zelle, Venmo, or cryptocurrency to settle an insurance matter.
Requests for sensitive personal information — Unsolicited callers asking for your Social Security number, banking details, or full credit card number should be treated with extreme caution.
Vague or inconsistent details — The caller cannot confirm specifics about your policy, or the story changes when you ask follow-up questions.
Pressure to keep it secret — A scammer may ask you not to discuss the matter with family members, your agent, or your financial institution.
Unsolicited contact after a disaster — Unlicensed contractors or adjusters showing up at your door following a storm or flood, often asking you to sign documents on the spot.
Our Commitment to You
We want to be completely transparent about how North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance Group communicates with our clients. Understanding what we will and will not do gives you a powerful tool to identify anyone impersonating us.
We will never pressure you to make an immediate payment using gift cards, wire transfers, cryptocurrency, or any other non-standard method.
We will never ask you to confirm sensitive personal information — such as your full Social Security number or bank account details — through an unsolicited call or email.
We will always be reachable through the verified contact information on our official website (www.ncfbins.com) and your policy documents. When in doubt, hang up and call us directly.
We will never threaten you with immediate legal action or policy cancellation to force an on-the-spot decision without giving you time to verify.
We are committed to protecting your information, your coverage, and your peace of mind — every single day.
What to Do If You're Targeted
If you receive a suspicious call, email, or visit from someone claiming to represent North Carolina Farm Bureau or any other insurance company, take a breath and follow these steps:
Do not provide any personal or financial information.
Hang up, close the email, or politely end the conversation. You owe no one your sensitive information on demand.
Do not click suspicious links or download attachments.
Even if an email looks like it came from a legitimate source, hover over links before clicking and verify the sender's email address carefully.
Call us directly using a verified number.
Use the phone number printed on your policy documents or found on www.ncfbins.com — never a number provided by the suspicious caller or email.
Alert your local Farm Bureau agent.
Let your agent know what happened so they can document it and help ensure your account remains secure. Find your local agent at www.ncfbins.com/find-agent
We're Here to Help
Fraud and scams are evolving every year, but so is our commitment to keeping our clients informed and protected. The single most powerful thing you can do when something feels wrong is slow down and verify. A legitimate representative of North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance Group will always give you the time and space to do that.
If you ever have questions about the authenticity of a communication, a suspicious offer, or anything related to your coverage, do not hesitate to reach out to your local Farm Bureau agent. We would rather take ten minutes to reassure you than have you become the victim of a scam that could have been avoided.
Other Resources

Common Questions
Questions about your bill or the claims process? Here are answers to questions that we are frequently asked.

Insurance Terms
Insurance terminology can seem complicated. This glossary might help you better understand your policy.
Contact Us
Customer Support
Our customer service team is available to answer your questions. Click below to contact us via email, or call us at (919) 782-1705 (M-F, 8:15 am – 5:00 pm, ET)
Email us: customerservice@ncfbins.com
Ask Your Agent
Our agents are always willing to help if you have any questions.
Contact Us By Mail
North Carolina Farm Bureau Insurance Group
P.O. Box 27427
Raleigh, NC 27611-7427